Its not a huge difference, but its not insignificant either. Dec 05, 2015 heres a side by side comparison of the data screens where i ran with the fitbit surge on one wrist and the garmin fenix 3 on the other. You can decide which fitness tracking device is best suited for you after carefully assessing the pros and cons of the two more popular fitness tracker brands fitbit and garmin vivofit. Fitbit surge vs garmin forerunner 35 vs garmin vivoactive. When comparing the fitbit surge vs garmin vivoactive, either one makes an excellent addition to anyones life.
Right now the apple watch sport, garmin vivoactive, and fitbit surge all attempt to capture the same potential audience, but with uniquely different features. Vivosmart and vivoactive, has given fitbit a run for its money. The garmin vivoactive is regarded as the superior wearable when it comes to function for sports minded individuals while the fitbit surge is seen as an elite smartwatch for everyday use. Garmin vivosmart is a very popular option on the higher end of the price range. Fitbit is one of the most wellknown fitness tracker companies. The blaze might be the new kid on the block, but this fitness superwatch is for those who are. Jan 11, 2016 verdict fitbit blaze vs garmin vivoactive. The surge is water resistant to 5atm up to 50 metres, which might sound like you can take it for a dip, but fitbit suggests you dont go any further than running in the rain or drenching it in sweat. What could be a deal breaker for some is waterproofing.
I have shortlisted garmin vivoactive 3 music vs fitbit ionic. Fitbit is one of the most wellknown fitness tracker companies out there. Also, over the last few months, ive been looking at either the garmin forerunner 735xt or 935 as a possible replac. Compare garmin vivoactive 3 vs garmin vivoactive hr garmin. Both watches are made for cycling, and both watches measure the distance you run or walk, and both trackers can measure your heart rate. When it comes to fitbit vs garmin, there is a wealth of amazing features and devices to be excited and interested in.
Its in the top 3 bestselling fitness trackers and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as polar v800 or polar v800 gps. Compared to its predecessor, the vivoactive, a lot has happened. Ive only ever heard complaints from people that have the surge. Shock gba800 casio wsdf10 casio wsdf20a diesel on full guard diesel on full guard 2. Fitbit surge is a defective product, the blaze is miles behind the garmin vivoactive hr imho. Garmin vivoactive hr vs fitbit surge comparison video.
Whereas the rest of this post is all about the fitbit to garmin migration piece. It is more difficult to move from high tech to higher tech. I tested it by counting my steps as i walked the the garmin was spot on. The fitbit surge is the daddy of the fitbit trackers. Fitbit charge hr vs garmin vivosmart hr urbanwearables. When calibrated correctly it can be used to determine altitude, which helps gps devices to lock on quicker and with greater accuracy. Compare fitbit surge vs garmin forerunner 910xt vs garmin. Comparison of fitbit ionic vs garmin forerunner 935 both fitness trackers are in the highprice range and both watches were released in 2017. Garmin wearables sit at the top of the league with their range of dedicated sports watches, such as the forerunner 920xt, epix and fenix 3. Its in the top 3 bestselling fitness trackers and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as dozenla smart wristband or huawei band 3 pro. So has it better, the fitbit versa or the garmin vivoactive 3. Fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3 vs apple watch 3. If you dont need all of that, then the fitbit surge is a reliable choice and it does have those additional band options.
Garmin vivoactive vs fitbit surge design and display. A battle between two fitness giants thats been debated for some time. And seriously, the vivoactive seems like a contender. Verdict with its vastly superior notifications and bulletproof gps and syncing, the garmin vivoactive is the. Each has builtin gps for mapping outdoor exercise and related statistics. It can predict weather changes, for example a sudden drop in air pressure could mean a storm is coming. I originally considered blaze vs vivoactive not hr. At the time of writing this article, garmin vioactive hr is number 1 best seller in running gps units, and fitbit surge number 9. Home fitness tracker comparison fitbit surge vs garmin vivoactive. Fitbit charge 2 is ranked 1st while garmin vivoactive hr is ranked 19th. Garmins new vivoactive hr wearable is designed to compete directly with fitbits surge. Are you an avid cyclist and finally want to add an activity tracker to your arsenal of cycle computers and pedal sensors.
Have you decided to make 2015 the year that you train for that 5k. Now i am in the market looking to buy a new tracker and i am in a dilemma on which one to go for. We would have to start pointing the fact that the garmin vivoactive hr is a newer model released in 2016, while fitbit surge was introduced to the market in 2015. Eventually i narrowed it down to the surge or vivoactive hr, as i require hr and gps with multisports tracking ability. The garmin vivoactive vs fitbit surge clash is near the top of the bill if youre seeking a highend fitness watch with a mixed bag of features. Dc rainmaker seems to love the garmin vivoactive hr and quite neatly points out the disparity in features available. Fitbit ionic vs garmin forerunner 935 compare fitness. Garmin vivoactive hr vs fitbit surge comparison video youtube. Fit bit ionic or garmin vivoactive 3 fitbit community. Garmin was also first to market with menstrual tracking though fitbit now offers that feature as well. Whether youre looking to shed a few pounds or you want to get more out of your workouts, a fitness. Youre asking in a garmin forum, so youll more than likely get people that enjoy the vivoactive hr more than the fitbit blaze.
Fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3 and other garmin devices. They are the most essential features that can be found in any fitness tracker such as. Compare fitbit charge 3 vs garmin vivosport fitbit. My surge, fitbits most expensive and premium tracker prior to ionic, had gotten. The vivoactive has more features, better build quality, built in gps, and better activity tracking. We received no monetary compensation from garmin or fitbit to provide this video. In order make our business sustainable and keep our content free, we use affiliate links. Fitbit charge hr vs garmin vivosmart hr view larger image the rivalry between fitbit and garmin goes back a few years to when garmin released the first vivofit in march 2014 to give the bestselling fitbit flex some competition, however, neither wearable featured a builtin heart rate monitor. There are a lot of newer fitness trackers on the market. If you click through using links on the site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Hi, i am new to the forum, but have been seaching for a fitness tracker for a few months.
These are two of the most popular quite possibly the best fitness trackers best activity trackers best fitness wristbands on the. The vivoactive 3 music, as the name implies, lets you load all your workout tunes and. While both are on the same page when it comes to style and price they each offer different extras and are geared towards different buyers. Garmin has been doing gps for quite a while and theyre very good at it.
This has a lightweight rubber band which is available in many different. The fitbit alta hr has a longer battery life but only by a hair. Garmins vivoactive hr is more hardcore than fitbits. This is garmins answer to the apple watch, the fitbit surge and all the rest of the smartwatches. These are arguably unmatched sporting wearables, and of. I cant decide whether to get the fit bit ionic, or the garmin vivoactive 3. Design sensors activity tracking connectivity battery features. I wanna use the sports watch for running,walking,and basketball. Garmin vivoactive vs fitbit surge is now available on the market, and it is difficult for you to choose which one is suitable for you. Apple watch vs fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3.
Nov 05, 2016 if you dont need all of that, then the fitbit surge is a reliable choice and it does have those additional band options. Tencloud for garmin vivoactive hr smartwatch and fitbit surge superwatch replacement band accessories silicone band holders keepers fastener rings loopsblack5 packs. Fitbit surge vs garmin fenix 3 healthy lifestyles kamado guru. Ask anyone about fitness trackers, and there is a high probability that they will mention garmin or fitbit, or both, and that should really come as no surprise. Fitbit ionic vs apple watch 3 vs garmin vivoactive 3. This first screen shot is the map drawn by the gps system on the fitbit surge. Heres how the new microsoft band 2 stacks up to the apple watch, fitbit surge and garmin vivoactive. While both units are priced the same, the vivoactive hr has approximately 3,283 more features than the fitbit surge. The design of a watch is important for lots of people and when it comes to the apple watch cs fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3 each other a different design and i think it all comes down to personal taste. I had pinged fitbit support who sent me a new surge but that had a horrible battery and died within 3 months. The garmin vivosmart lasts around six days before you need to charge it up again. It depends if youve drunk the fitbit koolaid around 247 optical hr tracking or not. This screen is the map created by the garmin fenix 3. The garmin s screen is slightly larger than the fitbit surge s 0.
Jun 27, 2016 dc rainmaker seems to love the garmin vivoactive hr and quite neatly points out the disparity in features available. Compare fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3 fitbit ionic vs. Find out which is better and their overall performance in the smartwatch ranking. Routine runners, cyclists and swimmers would benefit from the vivoactive, whereas those more interested in exercise intensity could find the blaze right up their street. In the question what are the best fitness trackers.
One last question between the fitbit blaze or surge and the vivoactive not the hr as we. The fitbit surge is a good example of a basic fitness smartwatch made by the brand. Find out which is better and their overall performance in the fitness tracker ranking. Apple watch sport vs fitbit surge fitness comparison. Dec 14, 2016 when i left fitbit for garmin i could only export 1 month of my fitbit history thats for premium members to. Fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3 vs samsung gear fit2 pro. The fitbit surge is a world away from the likes of the zip and the flex, and is definitely more smartwatch than activity tracker. What is the difference between garmin vivoactive 3 and fitbit blaze. This article will give a couple of information about garmin vivoactive vs fitbit surge that you need to know.
Gps activity trackers surge vs vivoactive hr warriorwomen. There are dozens of newer fitness trackers on the market. Looking at both devices, they are quite similar in terms of appearance and function. Both trackers measure the calories you burn every day. Fit bit ionic or garmin vivoactive 3 page 2 fitbit community. We stacked up the garmin vivoactive hr and the fitbit surge to find out which one is better suited for your. The garmin vivoactive hr comes in black and in two sizes. Fitbit needs to be charged vs garmin battery fitbit water resistant vs garmin waterproof to 50 feet.
Apple watch vs fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3 buyers. Oct 16, 2017 apple watch vs fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3 design. The fitbit surge comes in black, blue or tangerine and in three sizes. As of this article being published i am testing a new vivoactive to compare sidebyside to the fitbit surge my wife has used for the past few months. On a pure feature basis, theres really no competition here. It comes in three sizes and is made from a flexible, durable elastomer material similar to that used in sports watches.
To compare, i wore both a fitbit surge and the garmin vivofit fitness bands next to each other for over a month. Garmin vivoactive vs fitbit surge comparison smartwatch. When i left fitbit for garmin i could only export 1 month of my fitbit history thats for premium members to. Both watches have that extra dimension to them which goes beyond sport. Apr 03, 2015 at the other end of the cost spectrum are highend units that add gps andor heart rate monitoring, such as the fitbit surge or garmin vivoactive. It all boils down to your preference for getting fit. What is the difference between fitbit surge and garmin vivosmart. The workmanship and quality of all 3 fitness watches is very good, whereas the apple watch 3 stands out a little bit.
Compare fitness trackers and find their price, specifications, battery life and many other features. Both devices are fitness watches with some smartwatch notification capabilities. Fitbit surge vs garmin forerunner 35 vs garmin vivoactive hr. Garmin vivoactive 3 vs fitbit versa activity tracking. The surge and vivoactive are the 2 top devices when it comes to trackers, so choosing between them will come down to a matter of preference. Apple watch vs fitbit ionic vs garmin vivoactive 3 design. Fitbits strategy is to make whole bunch of different cheap models. When comparing garmin vivoactive hr vs fitbit charge 2, the slant community recommends fitbit charge 2 for most people. The look and feel of all three models can be adjusted, as their wristbands are interchangeable with others, such as leather bands. What is the difference between fitbit surge and garmin vivoactive. Garmin vivoactive vs fitbit surge battle of the activity. Garmin vivoactive is a very popular and one of the most expensive options. But the fitbit alta hr can be in constant use for a full seven days. Verdict with its vastly superior notifications and bulletproof gps and syncing, the garmin vivoactive is the top choice for fitness fans looking for more from.
That wont happen with garmin as it will allow you to export in the standard gpx file that most use. I got the vivoactive hr because it seems like a better device. Also, over the last few months, ive been looking at either the garmin forerunner 735xt or 935 as a possible replacement for my surge. The vivoactive has more clock faces which the blaze has lacked since it release. Just as when pdas blended into smart phones over a decade ago, were already starting to see more of these smart features migrate into all wearables. We stacked up the garmin vivoactive hr and the fitbit surge to find out which one is bettersuited for your needs. Which multisport wearable should you be reserving wrist space for. Apr 18, 2015 we received no monetary compensation from garmin or fitbit to provide this video. There is already a community thread comparing the ionic to the new apple watch, so i thought it might be useful to look of the pros and cons of the garmin vivoactive 3 in comparison. What is the difference between fitbit surge and garmin vivoactive hr.
1145 1252 728 894 109 1068 337 1358 70 1352 388 639 62 196 236 458 153 390 1061 741 58 724 937 532 1506 680 898 1408 168 1168 644 1087 538 1388 1093 52